Perspectives on clinician and VA involvement in prevention of firearm injuries

Veterans shared their thoughts on what the VA can do to prevent firearm injuries from occurring. Some talked about specific resources that the VA could provide, while others described expanding mental health services to civilian dependents. Veterans discussed their views on engaging with medical providers around the topic of firearm safety and storage. Some said that they would have no problem talking to a primary care provider (PCP) about firearms, while others expressed reluctance, or did not believe that such a conversation was appropriate in a clinical setting.

Communicating the prevalence and risks of unintended firearm injuries

Veterans we spoke with described the need for refresher courses in firearm safety and felt that the VA should highlight the prevalence of unintentional injuries among Veterans to help increase awareness. In Anthony’s view, “complacency is your worst enemy. I mean, it's like anything, you get so familiar with, let's say, your environment or if you're a chef, with your butcher knife. You know, a painter on a ladder; you become complacent.”
 
 

Mike suggests that the VA could provide refresher courses on firearm safety.

Mike suggests that the VA could provide refresher courses on firearm safety.

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

So, the VA can very much have resources on hand that if the Veteran needs it, say, "Here, this is a resource, get yourself a refresher course on how to be safe with that firearm," and have them, have those resources just as available as the suicide resources. Because I think that, like me, I tend to think suicide when you ask the question as opposed to somebody having an accidental discharge with the weapon. Because that's what Veterans deal with more is suicide. We don't think about the other stuff so I think that the resources need to be just as readily available.

 

Justice shares his thoughts on how the VA could share information about their work with accidental firearm injuries.

Justice shares his thoughts on how the VA could share information about their work with accidental firearm injuries.

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

I think I was almost naïve in the thinking that, “Oh, it could never happen to a military person.” Maybe if you heard like, “We’ve helped this many people recover from accidental discharge,” you may be a little bit more aware of a problem, or if it’s happening around you. I think it’s just almost taken for granted, firearm safety is sometimes. And if you heard, not personal stories, but like it still does happen. So, please still be careful and observe what you’re doing. It may help some people take a step back and realize, “Well, if it happened with these guys, it could happen to me too.”

 

 

Jack shares his thoughts on how the VA might reach Veterans about injury prevention.

Jack shares his thoughts on how the VA might reach Veterans about injury prevention.

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

So, off the cuff, I’m just thinking perhaps if in any communication or in some communication, at least once in a while, a one-time letter. And then, of course, as you get new Veterans, you’d have to mail the letter to them. Just something in the letter to say there have been Veterans who have been injured by handguns. Sometimes even their own handgun, accidentally after service. Sometimes of course, you have to go by the results of your survey. At least in my case, it’s just a matter of carelessness. Just not respecting the tool with the respect that it deserves. Just carelessness. So just—we just like to remind all Veterans, it can be worded much better than I could work it, better writer. But something to the effect of we care for Veterans. And we have Veterans who have lost their life or at least been wounded, injured. And we’d just like to encourage you, if you own firearms, to just please, don’t get careless. You’ve been around firearms maybe for many years. And you’re familiar with firearms, but just—and maybe put in there, I don’t know if this would be allowed or not, that we’ve done a survey. And something we’ve learned in the survey at least for many, whatever percent, that some say, “be careful.” If I received a letter like that, it would cause me to think. I do think it would. I just—and we’re just sending it. We’re not picking on anybody. We’re sending this out to all Veterans, combat Veterans, non-combat Veterans. Old Veterans, young Veterans, and even handsome Veterans like me.

Providing continued firearm safety training after military service 

Veterans described the importance of the military taking an active role in helping Veterans reintegrate into civilian life. Suggestions included investing in mental health resources for Veterans, hosting discussion forums about firearm ownership for those returning from deployment or upon their reintegration into society, and the importance of providing continued firearm safety training options outside of service. 
 
 

Jim talks about how post-deployment training could help prevent firearm injuries.

Jim talks about how post-deployment training could help prevent firearm injuries.

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

I think everybody that has been in the military needs to be sat down and explained the facts of life. We were trained to do a job, and we did it. Now it’s time to go home. And guns kill. They need to know that.

Force the military to set aside days, not hours or minutes, about the danger of firearms. Teach some people how to ask for help. That was one of my problems. I would never ask for help till later in life. Help is there for you, they just have to…you have to ask for

 

Nick feels the transition from military to civilian life could be an appropriate time to reiterate firearm safety.

Nick feels the transition from military to civilian life could be an appropriate time to reiterate firearm safety.

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

So, I think accessibility to information needs to be better when it comes to Veterans, as a whole. And then, number two, speaking specifically to that, I’m not sure if they do classes. I haven’t heard of it. But I think there needs to be a program the same way that you – it’s funny because there’s a checklist you have when you come into your first unit that you have to check off all of these things. You have to get certified in all these different categories, right? I think it needs to be a – the same checklist when you come home. But it needs to be more extensive. They do have one, but it’s not extensive enough, I feel like. I think it needs to be a full, you know, you need a full checklist of everything, you know? Like, every single thing. Firearm training. Firearm safety. How do you feel about firearms? Like, you know, actual specific focused therapy, conversation, presentation on firearm safety and the effects that it’s had on you, needs to be had for sure. That’s something that just needs to be created.

Providing Veterans with firearm safety devices

Veterans discussed resources and equipment the VA could provide to help prevent firearm injuries from occurring. Some suggested that free, VA-provided, safety devices may be helpful. Andy suggested that “it would be probably best if they would provide a firearm lock that would not take a key to utilize or unlock the guns. Basically, the firearm locks by fingerprint. When your adrenaline is pumping, you can’t even hardly put a key in the lock.”
 
 

Mike appreciates the VA providing firearm safety devices.

Mike appreciates the VA providing firearm safety devices.

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

That’s one thing I really appreciate. I don't know if all VAs do it, but I do know the VA here is very big on, if any Veteran walked in, and said, "I need a gun lock," I don't care if it's a behavioral health clinic or the women's clinic or the dental clinic, they're going to hand you a gun lock. And they're going to say, "Do you only need one? Because you can have ten.” So I am, I hope all VAs do that, but I'm very proud of the VA for providing that for Veterans.

 

Seth discusses ways the VA might connect with Veterans who are already receiving care in their facilities.

Seth discusses ways the VA might connect with Veterans who are already receiving care in their facilities.

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

That’s where I get my meds filled. That’s who gets me new...you know. So, if there is already this kind of connection around resources, there could at least be that connection made. It could be used as a cookie, too. “Hey, VA is giving away gun safes if you agree to talk to, you know, somebody who is going to call you up and ask you questions monthly for one year. And then it’s yours, we’re not going to bug you again.” But maybe those questions around— “Over the last month have you worn your firearm holstered? Have you put it in the safe every night? How many nights out of the week do you A, not bother, B, forget?” And kind of do something along those lines. 

 

Robert talks about trigger lock mechanisms and how they could be used to make weapons safer.

Text only
Read below

Robert talks about trigger lock mechanisms and how they could be used to make weapons safer.

HIDE TEXT
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

I am aware of some of the things that are good for weapons. They’ve got certain locks, you know, trigger locks when you are not using it, even if somebody picks it up, they can’t do anything with it with a trigger lock. They have like wire, woven wire, they almost look like small bicycle chains with a lock for them to keep people from being able to, you know, load one. It won’t allow the slide to come back all the way if they use it properly, that kind of thing. I have no issue with that at all. I think if there is something that the manufacturers can do to make a weapon safter and it doesn’t impede the ability to use the weapon, to use it in a lawful manner, I mean, I don’t have an issue with that at all. I think that’s probably an area that the successful big companies have been playing around with for a long, long time. They have all sorts of little things they’ve got going on.  

Integrating mental health services into care

Providing Veterans with adequate access to mental health services was viewed as an important factor in preventing firearm injuries. Veterans discussed the difficulties they faced navigating a mental health crisis, the circumstances that led to their own suicide attempt, or the weight of the traumatic stress they feel after witnessing a suicide. Please see the summary, “Mental health crises involving firearms,” for these accounts.
 
 

Johnny talks about how access to mental health care could help to prevent firearm injuries.

Johnny talks about how access to mental health care could help to prevent firearm injuries.

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

Mental healthcare—100%, because 95% of firearm injuries are self-inflicted. It’s something stupid like that. I might not be exactly right on the number, but I know it’s something stupid high like that. Matter of fact, not too long—well, a year and half ago, I had—a brother of mine is in that statistic now. So, I’ve had a few of them the last—I think we’ve lost more to self-inflicted gunshot wounds from my old battalion that we did to the enemy. Yeah. Mental health is a serious, serious—there is a serious need for good mental health in the VA system. And I don’t see it changing because they’ve known it for 15 years or more that it’s been a shortcoming, and they’re not fixing it.

  

Perspectives on clinicians asking about firearm ownership and safety practices

Veterans we spoke with were ambivalent about the idea of clinicians asking their patients about firearms ownership and storage practices during a medical encounter. One Veteran explained, “part of me is, like, ‘No, none of your business.’ But then, another part of me is like, ‘Yeah, I don't see why not.’ I don't see why there is an issue, especially if it's, like, the idea is that the person that you're seeing, the doctor, or the clinician, or the primary care provider is professional. They keep your information confidential.” Other Veterans shared strong feelings about opening up to healthcare providers about their firearm practices. Some were comfortable with the idea of talking with their primary care provider and support staff, while others were uncomfortable because they felt it had “nothing to do with my health care.”
 
 

Nick suggests "bringing it up in conversation, very nonchalant” might make it easier for Veterans to open up to their provider about their firearm practices.

Nick suggests "bringing it up in conversation, very nonchalant” might make it easier for Veterans to open up to their provider about their firearm practices.

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

I mean I guess one thing you could do is just, you know, bring it up in conversation when you see a Vet. Say, you know, “Have you purchased firearms since you’ve been home? How many do you have?” Dah, dah, dah. I think bringing it up in conversation very nonchalant and smooth would be a good way. Because what people don’t understand is like vets do be wanting to talk to people. You know, it’s some –it just takes more – some of us longer to open up. But we just we want somebody to care. And one thing my therapist said is like people that join the military have a deep level of care for people. They just want to help. They just want to help people. So, to help the people that want to help people is – it’s a beautiful thing. And sometimes you gotta practice and push a little bit. But once you do and they get comfortable, they’ll –they’ll share anything with you, you know. And that’s somewhere I’m at, at this point in my life. I’m an open book because vulnerability is courage to me at this point.

 

Jessica feels it could be left up to the patient whether or not they want to discuss the topic with their provider.

Jessica feels it could be left up to the patient whether or not they want to discuss the topic with their provider.

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

Oh, gosh. I think I might be in the minority on this just because of my impression of gun culture. But because I believe that guns, and gun safety, and gun violence are a public health issue, if my primary care doctor started asking me about my decisions about how to keep and store my firearms, I would think that would be a welcome addition to my care; and for someone who takes that very seriously and who appreciates the statistics, and who thinks this is a public health issue--because it is--I would welcome that. And I would hope that others would be welcoming of it or, at least, they would treat it as something that they could decline if they don’t want to discuss, just like any other health issue, that they would have the right to decline. Because I think that’s the main thing is just having the choice to say, "Yes, I want to have the discussion," or "No, I don’t want to have the discussion." Kind of like when you go to the pharmacy, "Yes, please give me advice on this medication," "No, I declined advice on this medication." I think as long as choice is a part of it, then there would, I would hope, be less pushback on that.  

I think even for someone who believes the way I do and as comfortable as I am advocating for gun safety, as comfortable as I am not having the popular opinion about gun culture, I would still feel nervous talking to my doctor about gun safety; even though it’s a conversation I would welcome, I would still feel that, perhaps, there was an opportunity for judgment there. And I would be very nervous if they were actually able--if they thought that I made decisions that were unsafe and that they were then able to act on that with local authorities or infringed upon my freedoms in any way based on the information that I gave them.

 

Jeff says he wouldn’t have an issue talking with a provider about firearms, but he knows that other Veterans might be reluctant.

Jeff says he wouldn’t have an issue talking with a provider about firearms, but he knows that other Veterans might be reluctant.

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

You know, I mean personally, I would have to. “Yes, I own one.” And would have to give him, you know, if I admitted own one, I would be participating in, choosing to participate in the conversation and I would have to answer further questions he wanted. Again, that goes back to the, “Why you asking me about my gun?” Even I, I can look at what the extremist views are on a lot of things and don’t agree with them. I’m pretty center of the road libertarian, but at the same time, I am still influenced by it, because the first, when you asked that question, the first thing that popped in my head, “Why you want to know about my guns?” But I mean. I said, it’s got really, really emotional and polarizing on the firearms, so. Me personally, I don’t think I would have a problem with it, but I can see where that would be a hot button issue for an avid gun owner being asked them questions. God, I don’t know if there is any way to fix is long term with just a VA program.

 

 

Bill is against a provider asking about firearms, but he understands that the conversation could be important in certain situations.

Bill is against a provider asking about firearms, but he understands that the conversation could be important in certain situations.

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

I have never been personally faced with a healthcare provider asking that question. I think in general it’s wrong. You’re prying into somebody’s personal life. And in most cases, it has no bearing on their healthcare, the reason they’re in there for that reason. But there’s always going to be those cases, always going to be those cases where there’s going to be a person that’s at risk, that they’re having some kind of mental crisis for whatever reason and that might be important information.

 

William A says that he would not feel comfortable talking to a provider about firearms

William A says that he would not feel comfortable talking to a provider about firearms

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

I don't know. I know how I would feel if they started asking me questions about my guns. That has nothing to do with my healthcare. Yeah, I don't know. It's, I think some people – I mean, there are disgruntled Veterans out there. 

Ideas on who should engage in conversations with Veterans about firearms 

Instead of discussing their firearm practices with their care providers, several Veterans suggested that others, such as their peers, might be more appropriate to lead this type of conversation as they are uniquely equipped with their own military experience. These Veterans felt the key to encouraging open conversations about issues related to firearms is to engage someone they can relate to and who has experience with firearms. Without the proper knowledge, Tom says “the message gets lost.”
 
 

Mike feels that certain VA team members would be most suitable to discuss firearm storage issues.

Mike feels that certain VA team members would be most suitable to discuss firearm storage issues.

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

Maybe if those questions were asked by somebody that, like, a nurse or a tech in the office that the Veteran interacts with more; and would be more prone to be more open with than the actual PCP? I know some Veterans that would feel more comfortable with somebody they interact with more. And I think for, there are other Veterans that would appreciate having that conversation with somebody that they know is not anti-firearm. Like a, have a – I don't know if you really need to have a job in the VA, but maybe volunteers. I don't know exactly how that would be set up; I'd have to think about that. But I know some Veterans would find that an easier conversation with somebody. I think that the PCP, you just don't talk to 'em. What, 15 minutes every six months to a year? Yeah, I can see where a lot of Veterans are very uncomfortable with that. 

 

Tom thinks that peer-to-peer counseling would be useful in firearm injury prevention efforts.

Tom thinks that peer-to-peer counseling would be useful in firearm injury prevention efforts.

SHOW TEXT VERSION
PRINT TRANSCRIPT

You know, especially for me and I know other Veterans feel this way. It’s got to be somebody that knows what they’re talking about and has had experiences. And you know has shared experiences with you. So, you know, me as a combat Veteran, if I’m going to talk to somebody about something like that, then I want to talk to somebody that knows what they’re talking about. You know, they’ve got experience with it. They can relate in a way that somebody that doesn’t have that experience or doesn’t have the training would be lost. And then, you know, you just get into psychological gobblty gook and, you know, the message gets lost.